Harieta Mareci-Sabol

“The Ugly Disease of Poverty”. Descriptions, Reports and Socio-Medical Measures to Combat Pellagra in Bukovina, 1890-1914

Harieta Mareci-Sabol

Article Information

Pages: 89-112

DOI: https://doi.org/10.24193/RJPS.2024.2.05

Harieta Mareci-Sabol

Ştefan cel Mare University of Suceava, no. 13-14 Universităţii St., Suceava, 720229, Romania, harieta@atals.usv.ro

Abstract. The health situation and the functioning of the Austrian Bukovina health system remain poorly understood due to the marginalization of the topic as well as the limited study of primary source material related to this time frame and region. Although scattered in the archives of Romania or those of Ukraine (Cernăuţi/Chernivtsi), in the regional press and popularization works specific to the beginning of the 20th century, the material concerning the variety of diseases (many of them infectious, with fatal effects among the population) is rich and instrumental in understanding the knowledge the historical specificities of the easternmost province of the monarchy. Based on such diverse information from the archives of Suceava and the press of the time, the article proposes to shed light on one of the most challenging “social diseases” of the time, namely pellagra. It presents the conditions and appearance of the disease, its symptoms and phases of manifestation (as described by several doctors from Cernăuţi and Suceava) and how the doctors and political authorities of the time adopted medical and social “sanitation” measures. The successes and setbacks in what had been dubbed the “Fight against Pellagra” (Bekampfung der Pellagra) for several decades point to the potential for examining the topic from the perspective of social history, ethnohistory, medical history, historical demography, and rural history, thus offering ideas for new investigations.

 Keywords: nutritional deficiency, social disease, medicalization, Bukovina, recovery, pellagra

 

References

Archival and media sources

N.A.R.S.C.S. National Archives of Romania, Suceava County Service, Fund “Suceava Town Hall” 1903. N.A.R.S.C.S. National Archives of Romania, Suceava County Service Fund “Prefectura Suceava” 1910.

Lupu O. (1978). Aspecte din istoria medicinii în Bucovina sub dominaţia habsburgică [unpublished manuscript], Suceava: Biblioteca Bucovinei “ I.G. Sbiera”.

Press sources

[S.N.] (1905). “Eine Wahnung an den Grafen Bylandt”. Bukowinaer Post 12 (1727): 1.

[S.N.] (1908). “Pellagröse Geisteskranke”. Bukowinaer Post 15 (2238): 5.

[S.N.] (1914). “Die Volkskrankheit der Bukowina”. Bukowinaer Post 21 (3161) 5: 1-2.

[S.N.] (1899). “Unglücksfälle”. Bukowinaer Rundschau 18 (2998): 3.

[S.N.] (1900). “Erhängt”. Bukowinaer Rundschau 19 (3351): 3

[S.N.] (1906). “Die Pellagra in der Bukowina”. Bukowinaer Rundschau 25 (5165): 3.

[S.N.] (1910). “Curăţenia casei şi a trupului omenesc – poveţe pentru popor date de Dr. O. G.”. Calendar pe 1911 24: 49-55.

[S.N.] (1908). “Pellagröse Geisteskranke”. Czernowitzer Allgemeine Zeitung” (1234): 4.

[S.N.] (1910). “Der Landtag”. Czernowitzer Tagblatt 8 (2084): 1-4.

[S.N.] (1914). “Korbflechterei Schule.— Bekämpfung der Pellagra”. Czernowitzer Tagblatt 12 (3422): 5.

[S.N.] (1904). “Contra pelagrei”. Deşteptarea 12 (71): 3.

[S.N.] (1895). “Despre Suceveni”. Gazeta Bucovinei 5 (73): 3.

[S.N.] (1896). “Alcoolismul”. Gazeta Bucovinei V6 (92): 3.

[S.N.] (1910). “Legea despre combaterea pelagrei”. Patria V (8): 3.

[S.N.] (1889). “Facultatea de medicină la universitatea din Cernăuţi”. Revista Politică 4(21): 1.

[S.N.] (1908). “Der Erbfeindder Bukowiner Bauern”. Die Wahrheit” 2 (7-8): 23-27.

Secondary literature

Covalciuc, D. (2018). “Ţărani în Consiliul Naţional din Bucovina”. Ţara Fagilor. Almanah cultural-literar al românilor nord-bucovineni” 27: 63-78.

Dan, D. (1908). “Pelagra”. Deşteptarea 1(4): 62-66.

Devetak, R. (2024). “Boj proti pelagri na Goriškem in Gradiškem v obdobju Avstro-Ogrske”. In Keber K. (ed.). Epidemije in Zdravstvo: Zgodovinski pogled. Ljubljana: ZRC SAZU, Zgodovinski inštitut Milka Kosa, pp. 233-257.

Diaconu, M.A. (2021). “Mais que mange-t-on en Bucovine ?! Esquisse d’un conflit vs. dialogue culturel”. Transylvanian Review 30(2): 103-114.

Felix, I. (1901). Istoria igienei în România în secolul al XIX-lea şi starea ei la începutul secolului al XX-lea. Bucureşti: Institutul de Arte Grafice Carol Göbl.

Flamm, H. (2021). “Die Pellagra – vor 250 Jahren im Kaisertum Österreich erstmals beschrieben, wurde sie zu einer lebensbedrohenden Endemie in einigen Provinzen”. Wiener klinische Wochenschrift 133 (Suppl. 1): 1–21.

Gentilcore, D., Priani, E. (2023). Pellagra and Pellagrous Insanity During the Long Nineteenth Century. Palgrave Macmillan.

Ginnaio, M. (2011). “Pellagra in Late Nineteenth Century Italy: Effects of a Deficiency Disease”. Population 66 (3-4): 583-609.

Gregor, A. (1911). “Pellagra and the Psychoses”. Alienist and Neurologist 32: 600-525.

Hacquet, B. (2002). “Recentele călătorii fizico-politice ale lui Haquet în anii 1788 şi 1789 prin Munţii Dacici şi Sarmatici sau Carpaţii Nordici.”. In Grigorovici, R. (ed.). Bucovina în prima descriere fizico-politică. Călătorie în Carpaţii Dacici (1788-1789). Rădăuţi: Septentrion, pp. 2-108.

Kluczenko, B. (1889). “Ueber das Vorkommen der Pellagra in der Bukowina”. Wiener Klinische Wochenshrift 2(3): 47-49.

Kluczenko, B. (1904). Sanitäts-Bericht der Bukowina für die Jahre 1901 bis 1903. Czernowitz: K.K. Landesregierung.

Klunczenko, B. (1911a). “Die Bekämpfung der Pellagra in der Bukowina im Jahre 1909”. Bukowinaer Post 18 (2635): 4-5.

Klunczenko, B. (1911b). “Die Bekämpfung der Pellagra in der Bukowina im Jahre 1909”. Bukowinaer Post 18 (2638): 4.

Klunczenko, B. (1911c). Sanitätsbericht der Bukowina für die Jahre 1907, 1908 und 1909. Czernowitz: K.K. Landesregierung.

Jászi, O. (1929). The Dissolution of the Habsburg Monarchy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Manolescu, G. (1904). “Pelagra”. Deşteptarea 12 (61): 2.

Mareci Sabol, H. (2017a). “Când boala este adusă de mâncare”. Consideraţii asupra pelagrei în Bucovina. Suceava. Anuarul Muzeului Bucovinei 43: 103-112.

Mareci Sabol, H. (2017b). “Poverty or Ignorance? The Challenge of Social Diseases in Bukovina around 1900”. Codrul Cosminului 33 (1): 31-50.

Marian, S.F. (2010). Botanica poporană română. Bucureşti: Editura Academiei Române.

Neagoe, I. (1900). Studiu asupra pelagrei. Bucureşti: Institutul de Arte Grafice Carol Göbl.

Neusser, E. (1887). Die Pellagra in Österreich und Rumänien, Wien: Alfred Hölder.

Niles, G.M. (1912). Pellagra. An American Problem. Philadelphia and London: W.B.Saunders Company

Philipowicz (1888). “Beobachtungen über das Vorkommen von Pellagra in der Bukowina”. Wiener Medizinische Blätter 11 (14): 422-424, (15) 453-455.

Prinzing, F. (1906). Handbuch der medizinischen Statistik, Jena: G. Fischer.

Savvidou, S. (2014). “Pellagra: A Non-Eradicated Old Disease”. Clinics and Practice 4 (1): 637.

Splény, G. (1998). “Descrierea districtului bucovinean”. In Grigorovici, R. (ed.). Bucovina în primele descrieri geografice, istorice, economice şi demografice. Bucureşti: Editura Academiei Române, pp. 9-219.

Würzel, M. (1903). “Ueber die Pellagra mit Berücksichtigung ihres Vorkommens im südlichen Teile der Bukowina”. Wiener Klinische Wochenshrift 16 (8): 211-218.